Instant Pot · Chicago heat · Sandwich build

Skeeter’s Chicago Hot BBQ Pulled Pork

Skeeter’s Chicago Hot BBQ Pulled Pork isn’t traditional barbecue — it’s Chicago barbecue. Sweet meets tang, and giardiniera delivers the city’s signature slow burn. Tender, deeply sauced pork stacked on a toasted Hawaiian bun with wet-style coleslaw, built for people who like their comfort food with an edge.

Yield8 sandwichesPrep15 minCook75 minTotal90 min
Skeeter's Chicago Hot BBQ pulled pork sandwich with coleslaw on a toasted bunSKEETER’S · CHICAGO HOT
Chicago rule: This isn’t “traditional BBQ.” Chicago is the city that puts sauce on top of pizza and sport peppers on hot dogs. Giardiniera is the spice that defines Chicago Hot.

Ingredients

Pulled Pork

  • 1 package pork tenderloins (about 2–3 lbs total)
  • Montreal steak seasoning (season liberally)
  • Extra virgin olive oil spray
  • 1 cup water
  • 1/4 cup Potbelly giardiniera (include the briny oil)
  • 1/4 cup pepperoncini juice
  • 1 cup Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce (for cooking)
  • Additional BBQ sauce for finishing

For Serving

  • 8 Hawaiian burger buns
  • Butter for toasting buns
  • Wet-style coleslaw (homemade or store-bought from the deli)
  • Extra giardiniera for garnish

Instructions

  1. Rinse and pat dry

    Rinse the pork tenderloins and pat completely dry. Do not trim the fat; tenderloin is lean enough already, and the remaining fat contributes flavor.

  2. Cut into chunks

    Cut each tenderloin into 4–5 large chunks so the pieces sear evenly and quickly.

  3. Season liberally

    Season all sides of the pork liberally with Montreal steak seasoning.

  4. Sear the pork

    Set the Instant Pot to Sauté and lightly spray the bottom with extra virgin olive oil. Brown the pork chunks on all sides, working in batches if needed. Let each side sit long enough to form the browned bits on the bottom of the pot.

  5. Remove and reserve

    Transfer the seared pork to a plate and reserve the juices.

  6. Deglaze the pot

    Add 1 cup water and 1/4 cup pepperoncini juice. Use a wooden spoon to scrape up all the savory browned bits from the bottom of the pot.

  7. Build the cooking sauce

    Stir in 1/4 cup Potbelly giardiniera, including its briny oil, and 1 cup Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce.

  8. Pressure cook

    Return the pork and any reserved plate juices to the pot. Seal the Instant Pot and cook on High Pressure for 60 minutes.

  9. Quick release and shred

    Carefully perform a quick pressure release following your Instant Pot’s instructions. Remove the pork and shred it.

  10. Moisten and sauce

    Stir the liquid left in the pot. Reserve 1/3 cup of that cooking sauce and mix it into the shredded pork. Add more Sweet Baby Ray’s BBQ sauce to your preference.

  11. Fold in the peppers

    Skim the cooked giardiniera pieces from the pot and fold them into the sauced pork.

  12. Toast the buns

    Butter the cut sides of the Hawaiian buns and brown them in a frying pan as you would grilled cheese.

  13. Build the sandwiches

    Pile pulled pork onto the toasted buns. Top with wet-style coleslaw and garnish with extra giardiniera to taste. Serve immediately.

Skeeter's Notes

  • Want it hotter? Add more giardiniera (including the oil) while cooking and/or garnish with extra on top.
  • If you’re not getting browned bits during searing, you’re not letting the pork sit long enough on each side. Those brown bits are flavor — be patient.
  • Mix 1/3 cup of the reserved cooking sauce into the shredded pork first, then add additional BBQ sauce to your preference for sweetness and wetness.